In this paper, I argue that a principle of rectification for past wrongdoings could and should be added to Rawls's Law of Peoples on the ground that unrectified past injustice undermines the notion of equality of peoples. I base this work on a conception of rectification that includes apologies as well as economic compensation, and I focus on the step of compensation. To do so, I briefly discuss how the maximin decision rule can adapt to the second original position. To (...) address the compatibility of rectificatory justice with Rawls's work, I focus on the strains of commitment and consider Rawls's account of peoples' fundamental interests. Rawls's conception of international justice needs to be responsive to peoples' fundamental interest in equality, which calls for proper protection of their means of self‐respect. Although the moral imbalance stemming from past injustice is overlooked in The Law of Peoples, I show that Rawls's theoretical framework can ground a principle of rectification. (shrink)

Derrière un titre assez sobre, la structure de l’ouvrage de R. Gagné (R.G.) permet d’entrevoir son originalité. Loin de se contenter d’une brève circonscription du concept de faute ancestrale dans l’introduction, l’A. consacre les deux premiers chapitres à la réception et à la réinterprétation de cette notion après l’Antiquité. Il cherche ainsi à montrer par quels filtres successifs a transité la notion avant d’arriver jusqu’à nous. Ce n’est qu’après un exposé assez érudit sur les nombreux au...

Cette étude montrera que la confirmation expérimentale des conjectures constituait chez Galilée l’objet d’un souci constant, et ce dès le début de son activité scientifique. À l’appui de cette thèse, je citerai ses premiers travaux expérimentaux et montrerai avec quelle profondeur il était capable d’analyser par lui-même ses résultats. Je démontrerai ensuite qu’il a discuté de ses résultats avec d’autres scientifiques afin de confirmer ses intuitions initiales. C’est en les consultant et en bénéficiant de leurs conseils qu’il put mener ses (...) intuitions à leur état final. (shrink)

Resumen En los días actuales, la democracia se resiente de la escalada virtual-tecnocrática, un incremento de la virtualidad sin precedentes. Los cambios redefinen no solo las formas de interacción entre los sujetos, sino pasan a influenciar la toma de decisiones. La virtualidad se transforma en un único medio para manejar las materias de interés público, sin compromiso moral. El aspecto central se relaciona a la gramática pronominal y al uso de los pronombres personales en la interacción comunicativa. Por eso, si (...) todos los sujetos tienen voz activa, ellos son coautores en la reconstrucción del consenso intersubjetivo, participantes activos de las justificaciones. Mientras tanto, a veces, la utilización del pronombre en la tercera persona pone en evidencia un sujeto presente, pero indeseado y molestador. Se trata de un sujeto en la voz pasiva, una forma de reconocimiento discriminatoria, actitud que niega su status de coautor.In the present days, democracy suffers from the virtual-technocratic climbing, an increase of virtuality unprecedented. Changes redefine not only the forms of interaction between subjects, but a/so influence decision making. The virtuality is transformed into a single means to handle matters of public interest without moral commitment. The central aspect is related to the pronominal grammar and the use of personal pronouns in the communicative interaction. Therefore, if all subjects have an active voice, they are co-authors in the reconstruction of the intersubjective consensus, active participants in the justifications. Meanwhile, sometimes, the use of the pronoun in the third person reveals a subject present, but unwanted and annoying. It is a subject in the passive voice, a form of discriminatory recognition, an attitude that denies its co-author status. (shrink)

The aim of the paper is to outline a treatment of cotenability inspired by a perspective which had strong roots in ancient logic since Chrysippus and was partially recovered in the XX Century by E. Nelson and the exponents of so-called connexive logic. Consequential implication is a modal reinterpretation of connexive implication which permits a simple reconstruction of Aristotle's square of conditionals, in which proper place is given not only to ordinary cotenability between A and B, represented by ¬, but (...) to its “secondary” variant ¬ . After showing that logics of strict implication, of Stalnaker-Lewis conditionals and of relevant implication do not satisfy the intuitive properties required for cotenability , it is proved that such conditions are satisfied by consequential cotenability and by its secondary variant . The notions of strong cotenability and of bilateral cotenability are then introduced: the latter stands to standard cotenabilty as contingency stands to possibility, and in Section 9 it is shown to be a useful tool in the reconstruction of Boethius' theory of adjuncta. (shrink)

Thick description was originally proposed to overcome the limitations of quantitative research and ground anthropological observations in concrete people’s expectations, rather than in normative theories. The ultimate objective was to account for the emotional aspects of worldviews and value-orientations that would otherwise be left tacit or implicit by quantitative investigations. The present paper aimed at reviewing the _conceptual framework_ that has characterized this relational turn and has made possible a deeper understanding of the subjective experience. The primary objective is thus (...) to make explicit the assumptions upon which thick description relies and discuss how these renewed conditions allow meaning to emerge in interpersonal relationships. We argue that both these objectives would be theoretically attainable if primarily centered on the exploration of the _possibility space_ and on the patient’s experience as driven by the power of _counterfactual thinking_. Under these conditions, human subjects may be led to recognize the contextual and semiotic dimension of _boundaries_ and, in so doing, become aware of the beneficial effects of weaving past and new experiences in meaningful relationships. (shrink)

In Logical Forms Chateaubriand introduces a disambiguation technique that might turn out to be highly useful for analyzing important classes of sentences. In particular, he claims that this technique is relevant for analyzing counterfactual suppositions. In this paper I critically examine this claim and conclude that the ambiguity of counterfactuals is contextual rather than structural.

The different and seemingly unrelated practices of Information and Communication Technologies used to collect and share personal and scientific data within networked communities, and the organized storage of human genetic samples and information—namely biobanking—have merged with another recent epistemic and social phenomenon, namely scientists and citizens collaborating as “peers” in creating knowledge. These different dimensions can be found in joint initiatives where scientists-and-citizens use genetic information and ICT as powerful ways to gain more control over their health and the environment. (...) While this kind of initiative usually takes place only after rights have been infringed —as the two cases presented in the paper show—collaborative scientists-and-citizens’ knowledge should be institutionally allowed to complement and corroborate official knowledge-supporting policies. (shrink)

Within the traditional conception of communication, the subjects involved in the communicative process are divided into emitter and receiver of the message, analogous to the mechanism of transmission and regulation between machines, which is called cybernetics, to which the communicative process between living beings is assimilated (Habermas & McCarthy, 1984; Shannon & Weaver, 1998; Wiener, 2019). According to this theory, the person capable of communicating can only be equated to a target, to be considered in the unidirectional transmission of information. (...) Consequently, “good communication” is considered exclusively from an economic and utilitarian point of view, so that “good” communication is that which effectively transmits a message and obtains the maximum result with the minimum of effort. (shrink)

Cet ouvrage se penche sur la question des transformations à l’œuvre dans les traditions rituelles des religions méditerranéennes antiques, avec une attention particulière portée aux acteurs à l’origine de ces changements ainsi qu’aux émotions suscitées. Plusieurs contributions sont issues de communications présentées dans le panel « agency » du colloque « Ritual Dynamics and the Science of Ritual », organisé à Heidelberg en 2008. Je résume ici les contributions portant sur le monde grec. L’an...

L’ouvrage de P. Ismard (P.I.) cherche à comprendre « le poids de l’événement que représente le procès de Socrate dans la mémoire occidentale » (p. 11). Cet objectif repose sur trois angles d’approche : il s’agit de saisir les enjeux du procès comme tel, d’utiliser cet « événement » comme clé d’analyse des institutions athéniennes contemporaines du procès, et d’étudier la réception du procès aux époques ultérieures. L’analyse est structurée autour de neuf chapitres, dans un langage fluide et a...

El presente trabajo se propone analizar el problema del lenguaje en dos pensadores de la _nouvelle phénoménologie_ francesa: Jean-Luc Marion y Claude Romano. Intentamos mostrar que la novedad de esta tradición consiste en mostrar que el lenguaje propio de la fenomenología puede ser explorado desde una dimensión no-predicativa. Para esto, proponemos agrupar estas propuestas bajo la noción de “lenguajes del exceso”. En relación a Marion, agruparemos sus diversas formulaciones sobre este tema bajo la idea de lo que denominaremos como “lenguaje (...) de la saturación”. El elemento central aquí será su recepción del neoplatonismo cristiano (Dionisio Areopagita y Nicolás de Cusa), la cual le permite formular un lenguaje para nombrar los fenómenos saturados. En cuanto a Claude Romano, aunque ajeno a la tradición del neoplatonismo cristiano, sostendremos que su propuesta fenomenológico-hermenéutica está al servicio de la búsqueda de un lenguaje que pueda denominar el acontecimiento. En ambos casos, los autores pretenden describir fenómenos que exceden el ámbito de los objetos. (shrink)

The paper studies the relation between systems of modal logic and systems of consequential implication, a non-material form of implication satisfying "Aristotle's Thesis" (p does not imply not p) and "Weak Boethius' Thesis" (if p implies q, then p does not imply not q). Definitions are given of consequential implication in terms of modal operators and of modal operators in terms of consequential implication. The modal equivalent of "Strong Boethius' Thesis" (that p implies q implies that p does not imply (...) not q) is identified. (shrink)

e debates acadêmicos, persiste um descrédito, pois os resultados evidenciam que apenas uma minoria consegue garantir seu bem-estar. Então, se não há mudanças econômicas e sociais, para que serve a democracia a não ser manter os privilégios de uma minoria? A adesão à teoria do agir comunicativo seria, pois, uma possibilidade para enfrentar o ceticismo dos niilistas, fundamentalistas e neoconservadores. O foco de análise remete ao desacoplamento entre sistema e mundo da vida. A disjunção separa e divide os diferentes subsistemas (...) para, deste modo, justificar a hegemonia dos aspectos econômico-financeiros. O resultado desse processo desagrega, não apenas estratos sociais, mas também culturas e estilos de vida. Ao salientar um único modelo, os demais são classificados como inferiores. Do ponto de vista filosófico, a tese da vontade da maioria serviu de alento para consolidar a vontade da minoria. No caso, a designação roussouniana do amour de soi serve, atualmente, como inspiração para justificar o solipsismo individualista. O autointeresse coaduna o realismo político com as necessidades de sobrevivência e de alimentar-se. Com isso, as motivações das escolhas racionais se vêm enfrentadas ao dilema de buscar a autorrealização em detrimento aos compromissos sociais e coletivos. Como alternativa, menciona-se a necessidade de uma espiritualidade capaz de garantir a polifonia das vozes capaz de religar as intersubjetividades dos distintos grupos e subsistemas. (shrink)

The first part of the paper contains a probabilistic axiomatic extension of the conditional system WV, here named WVPr. This system is extended with the axiom (Pr4): PrA = 1 ⊃ □A. The resulting system, named WVPr∗, is proved to be consistent and non-trivial, in the sense that it does not contain the wff (Triv): A ≡□A. Extending WVPr∗ with the so-called Generalized Stalnaker’s Thesis (GST) yields the (first) Lewis’s Triviality Result (LTriv) in the form (◊(A ∧ B) ∧◊(A ∧ (...) ¬B)) ⊃ PrB|A = PrB. In §4 it is shown that a consequence of this theorem is the thesis (CT1): ¬A ⊃ (A > B ⊃ A ⥽ B). It is then proven that (CT1) subjoined to the conditional system WVPr∗ yields the collapse formula (Triv). The final result is that WVPr∗+(GST) is equivalent to WVPr∗+(Triv). In the last section a discussion is opened about the intuitive and philosophical plausibility of axiom (Pr4) and its role in the derivation of (Triv). (shrink)

La filosofía práctica abre paso a diferentes temas. Se trata de entender el papel de la filosofía misma y, además, señalar sus implicaciones con la formación de las ideas. El caso de Alemania es especialmente significativo, donde la filosofía experimenta una especie de tensión entre la continuidad o la renovación. Esa tensión puede ser identificada también en América Latina o en Brasil, de modo especial por sus patrones foráneos y exógenos. Además del positivismo francés, hubo también una especie de Eugenia (...) racial. Lo que hoy se conoce de Brasil supone una trayectoria histórica que la filosofía intercultural exige reconstruir para entender la diversidad de sus matices y las características de su gente. The practical philosophy opens the way to different subjects. It treats to understand the role of the philosophy itself and, besides, to indicate its implication with the ideas formation. The German example is especial expressive, where the philosophy tries a kind of tension between the continuation and the renewal. This tension can be to found in Latin America or Brazil, specially by their foreign and external patterns. Besides the French positivism, there was a kind of racial Eugenie in Brazil. What we know about Brazil today supposes a historical course. The intercultural philosophy demands to reconstruct this course, so the diversity of nuances and the characteristic of people can be understood. (shrink)

The first part of the paper aims at showing that the notion of an Aristotelian square may be seen as a special case of a variety of different more general notions: the one of a subAristotelian square, the one of a semiAristotelian square, the one of an Aristotelian cube, which is a construction made up of six semiAristotelian squares, two of which are Aristotelian. Furthermore, if the standard Aristotelian square is seen as a special ordered 4-tuple of formulas, there are (...) 4-tuples describing rotations of the original square which are non-standard Aristotelian squares. The second part of the paper focuses on the notion of a composition of squares. After a discussion of possible alternative definitions, a privileged notion of composition of squares is identified, thus opening the road to introducing and discussing the wider notion of composition of cubes. (shrink)

After a summary of the steps taken by the Catholic Church in the aftermath of Galileos condemnation, in order to adapt itself to the progressive, universal acceptance of the heliocentric theory, the main part of the article deals with the xx century. It focuses first on the vicissitudes of the publication of Mons. Paschinis book on Galileo, which appeared only posthumously and with "corrections" towards the end of the Second Vatican Council. It then considers the working of the Galileo Commission, (...) instituted in 1981 as a concrete follow-up of the desire expressed by John Paul n, in his well known speech of 1979, to reach a final, unbiased judgement on the Galileo Affair. Such a judgment is contained in the speeches of cardinal Poupard and of John Paul II (1992), a critical appraisal of which is offered in the final part of the article. /// Depois de uma apresentação sumária dos passos dados pela Igreja Católica, na sequência da sua própria condenação de Galileu e, agora, em ordem a se adaptar à aceitação progressiva e universal da teoria heliocêntrica, a parte central do presente artigo debate sobretudo questões surgidas durante o século XX. Nesse sentido, o artigo trata em primeiro lugar das vicissitudes relativas à publicação do livro de Monsenhor Paschini sobre Galileu, publicação essa que acabou por acontecer apenas a título póstumo, e não sem significativas "correcções", na parte final do Concílio Vaticano II. Em seguida, o artigo analisa também os procedimentos da Comissão Galileu, instituída em 1981 como consequência directa do desejo expresso por João Paulo II no seu conhecido discurso de 1979 de que se chegasse a um juízo final e sem partidarismos acerca do Caso Galileu. Esse juízo está contido nos discursos do Cardeal Poupará e de João Paulo II (1992), discursos estes de que o artigo, nomeadamente na sua parte final, também oferece uma avaliação crítica. (shrink)