Abstract

In addition to the classic “A Defense of Abortion”, this volume contains twelve later papers by Mrs. Thomson, covering topics such as the right to life and the right to privacy, the redistribution of wealth through taxation, and the case for preferential hiring. For the most part, however, the issues raised are not ones that worry the layman. As a typical example, we agree that a surgeon may not kill a patient to obtain transplants to save five, and the problem is how to reconcile that with our acceptance that a trolley driver whose brakes fail may turn it and kill one, precisely to save five. That’s “a lovely, nasty difficulty,” which she deepens by querying the answer that, while killing is worse than letting die, the driver must kill one or five. We need only suppose that the driver faints, and that a bystander can do nothing, or redirect the car. If he may act, the original problem returns.